Software

Building Your First Product Team: A Founder's Guide

Andres Max Andres Max
· 14 min read
Building Your First Product Team: A Founder's Guide

The hardest part of building a product isn’t writing code. It’s building the team that writes the code.

After helping 500+ developers and designers find roles and scaling teams from 3 to 80+ people at companies like Qrvey, I’ve seen every hiring mistake possible. I’ve also seen what works.

This guide covers everything I wish I’d known before building my first product team: when to hire, who to hire first, how to structure roles, and how to create a culture that actually ships products.

Before You Hire: Do You Actually Need a Team?

The biggest mistake founders make is hiring too early.

You don’t need a product team if:

  • You haven’t validated product-market fit
  • You’re still experimenting with your MVP
  • Your product can be built with no-code tools
  • You can contract specialists for specific needs
  • Revenue doesn’t justify salaries

You DO need a product team when:

  • You have repeatable customer demand
  • You’re scaling beyond what contractors can handle
  • You need domain expertise in-house
  • Product complexity requires specialized roles
  • Revenue supports 3-6 months of runway for new hires

Alternative: The Pod Model

Before committing to full-time hires, consider the pod approach where you get a complete team on-demand. Many of my clients validate their product with a pod, then convert key members to full-time once they’ve proven product-market fit.

This de-risks the biggest expense (salaries) while you’re still figuring things out.

The First Hire: Who Should It Be?

This depends entirely on your strengths and weaknesses as a founder.

If You’re a Technical Founder

Option 1: Hire a Product Designer First

Why: You can code, but you need someone who understands users and can design experiences that people actually want to use.

Green lights to hire a designer:

  • You have customers but they find the product confusing
  • You’re building UI based on what “looks good” not what works
  • You spend hours on visual decisions that don’t matter
  • You skip user research and flow design

What to look for:

  • Portfolio showing process work (research, wireframes, flows) not just polished screenshots
  • Experience with early-stage products (not just enterprise or agency)
  • Can work autonomously with minimal direction
  • Asks about users and business goals in interview

Option 2: Hire a Full-Stack Engineer

Why: You need to ship faster and can’t build everything yourself.

Green lights to hire an engineer:

  • You have a clear product roadmap for 6+ months
  • You’re the bottleneck on shipping features
  • Technical debt is piling up
  • You need someone to own parts of the codebase

What to look for:

  • Can ship end-to-end (frontend + backend + deploy)
  • Comfortable with ambiguity and changing requirements
  • Has early-stage startup experience
  • Excited by product problems, not just technical challenges

Option 3: Hire a Product Manager

Why: You’re technical but struggle with prioritization, user research, and stakeholder management.

Green lights to hire a PM:

  • You have multiple customer segments with competing needs
  • You struggle with prioritizing features
  • You need someone to talk to customers regularly
  • You want to focus on technical architecture, not product decisions

What to look for:

  • Experience with technical products (can talk to engineers)
  • Strong customer discovery skills
  • Data-driven decision making
  • Can say “no” to features based on evidence

If You’re a Non-Technical Founder

Hire a Technical Co-Founder or CTO First

Don’t outsource your first product development. You need technical leadership who’s invested in the business, not contractors who disappear after the project.

If you can’t find a technical co-founder:

  • Use the pod model to validate and build MVP
  • Hire a fractional CTO to architect the system
  • Once validated, hire full-time senior engineer
  • Never hire junior engineers as your first technical hire

Your First Product Team: The Core Trio

Once you’re past your first hire, the optimal early team is 3-4 people:

The Ideal Structure (3-4 People)

1. Product Designer - Owns user experience and product design 2. Full-Stack Engineer - Ships features end-to-end 3. Product Manager or Technical Lead - Prioritizes, coordinates, removes blockers

This trio can ship complete features without dependencies. Add a second engineer when the first is overloaded.

Roles and Responsibilities

Product Designer:

  • User research and customer interviews
  • User flows and information architecture
  • Wireframes and prototypes
  • Visual design and design system
  • Usability testing

Full-Stack Engineer:

  • Feature development (frontend + backend)
  • Code review and technical decisions
  • Infrastructure and deployment
  • Bug fixes and technical debt
  • Performance optimization

Product Manager/Lead:

What You DON’T Need Early

Don’t hire these roles until later:

  • Dedicated QA - Engineers should test their own code early on
  • DevOps specialist - Use managed services (Vercel, Railway, Render)
  • Marketing - Focus on product-market fit first
  • Data analyst - Founders can analyze data initially
  • Customer support - Founders should talk to early customers

Hiring specialists too early fragments the team and slows shipping.

How to Find Great People

The best hires rarely come from job boards. Here’s where I’ve found exceptional product people:

The Network Approach (Highest Success Rate)

1. Ask Your Network Post on LinkedIn/Twitter: “Looking for a [role] who loves early-stage products. Know anyone?”

Your network’s referrals are pre-vetted and more likely to fit culturally.

2. Poach from Companies You Admire Identify companies building products you respect. Find people on LinkedIn who work there in your target role. Reach out directly.

Message template:

“Hey [Name], I’m building [product] and noticed your work at [Company]. Would love to chat about [specific thing they’ve built]. Are you open to exploring new opportunities?”

3. Engage in Communities

  • Designer communities: Dribbble, Designer News, ADPList
  • Engineering communities: GitHub, Dev.to, Hacker News
  • Product communities: Product Hunt, Indie Hackers, Lenny’s Newsletter

Contribute first, recruit second.

The Job Board Approach (Lower Success Rate)

If you must use job boards:

  • AngelList - Startup-focused talent
  • LinkedIn - Broad reach, but noisy
  • We Work Remotely - Remote-first candidates
  • Hacker News Who’s Hiring - Technical talent

Make your job post stand out by focusing on:

  • The problem you’re solving (not the features you’re building)
  • What they’ll own and learn
  • Small team = high impact
  • Compensation range (transparency attracts serious candidates)

Red Flags in Job Searches

Avoid candidates who:

  • Only worked at large companies (struggle with ambiguity)
  • Job hop every 6-12 months (pattern of quitting when it gets hard)
  • Can’t articulate why they want to join early-stage
  • Focus only on compensation, not mission
  • Have no side projects or curiosity (especially for engineers)

The Interview Process That Actually Works

Most startups copy big company interview processes and hire the wrong people. Here’s what works for early-stage teams:

Stage 1: Initial Screen (30 min)

Goals:

  • Confirm they understand what early-stage means
  • Assess communication skills
  • Check for basic competence
  • See if there’s mutual excitement

Questions to ask:

  • “Why are you interested in early-stage vs. established companies?”
  • “Walk me through a project you’re proud of from start to finish”
  • “What’s your ideal work environment?”
  • “What are you optimizing for in your next role?”

Stage 2: Work Sample (2-4 hours, paid)

Skip whiteboard coding and design challenges. Give them real work.

For Engineers: Small feature or bug fix in your actual codebase

  • Pay them $200-500 for the time
  • Review code quality, communication, and approach
  • See if they ask good questions

For Designers: Design a small feature based on real customer feedback

  • Pay them $200-500
  • Look for process (research, flows, iterations) not just visuals
  • See if they understand the business problem

For PMs: Review customer feedback and create a prioritization framework

  • Pay them $200-500
  • Assess how they think about trade-offs
  • Check data-driven decision making

Stage 3: Team Fit (1-2 hours)

Have them meet the team they’d work with:

  • Pair programming or design session
  • Lunch or coffee (casual environment)
  • Ask the team: “Would you want to work with this person every day?”

Stage 4: Values and Vision (1 hour)

Final conversation with founder(s):

  • Share your vision and see if they’re excited
  • Discuss working style and outcome-based culture
  • Talk compensation and expectations
  • Check references

Reference Checks That Matter:

Don’t ask “Was this person good?” Ask:

  • “What was their biggest strength?”
  • “What was one area they could improve?”
  • “Would you hire them again if you could?”
  • “How did they handle feedback?”

The pause before answering tells you everything.

Compensation: What to Pay

This is one of the hardest decisions for founders. Here’s the framework I use:

Base Salary Guidelines (US Market, 2025)

Full-Stack Engineer:

  • Junior (0-2 years): $80K-110K
  • Mid (3-5 years): $110K-150K
  • Senior (5+ years): $150K-200K

Product Designer:

  • Junior (0-2 years): $70K-95K
  • Mid (3-5 years): $95K-130K
  • Senior (5+ years): $130K-180K

Product Manager:

  • Junior (0-2 years): $80K-110K
  • Mid (3-5 years): $110K-145K
  • Senior (5+ years): $145K-190K

These are for high-cost US markets. Adjust down 20-30% for lower cost regions or remote-first roles.

Equity: How Much to Offer

First 5 Hires:

  • Employee #1: 0.5%-2%
  • Employees #2-5: 0.25%-1%

Hires 6-20:

  • Senior roles: 0.1%-0.5%
  • Mid-level roles: 0.05%-0.25%

Equity should vest over 4 years with 1-year cliff.

Cash vs. Equity Trade-Off

Some candidates will take lower cash for more equity. This can work if:

  • They have savings or other income
  • They truly believe in the mission
  • You’re transparent about the risk

Don’t lowball cash AND equity. That attracts desperate candidates, not great ones.

Building a Culture That Ships

Culture isn’t ping pong tables and free snacks. It’s how decisions get made and work gets done.

Principle 1: Outcomes Over Activity

Measure results, not hours worked. Set clear goals and trust people to manage their time.

In practice:

  • No time tracking
  • Flexible hours
  • Async communication
  • Weekly results reviews

Principle 2: Ship Fast, Iterate Faster

Move quickly and learn from real usage, not endless planning.

In practice:

  • 2-week sprint cycles
  • Ship to production weekly minimum
  • Feature flags for safe releases
  • User feedback loops

Principle 3: Default to Transparency

Share everything unless there’s a good reason not to.

In practice:

  • Public roadmap
  • Open financials (revenue, runway)
  • All-hands meetings weekly
  • Document decisions in writing

Principle 4: Customer Obsession

Build for users, not for competitors or your own preferences.

In practice:

Principle 5: Ownership and Autonomy

Hire adults, treat them like adults.

In practice:

  • Clear ownership of features/areas
  • Decision-making authority
  • Budget to solve problems
  • Permission to fail

Team Structure as You Scale

Here’s how team structure evolves:

1-3 People: Everyone Does Everything

No formal roles. Ship features, fix bugs, talk to users, handle support.

4-10 People: Specialize but Stay Flexible

Roles emerge but everyone still does multiple things. Designer might write CSS. Engineer might draft specs.

11-25 People: Small Teams (Pods)

Break into 2-4 small teams of 3-5 people each. Each team owns a product area or customer segment.

Example structure at 15 people:

  • Core Product Pod (5): PM, 2 engineers, designer, data
  • Growth Pod (4): PM, engineer, designer, marketer
  • Platform Pod (4): 3 engineers, technical PM
  • Leadership (2): Founder/CEO, Head of Product

25+ People: Departments and Management

You need formal management structure. VPs, team leads, specialists.

At this stage, hire a VP of Product or Engineering. Your job as founder shifts to vision, culture, and strategy.

Common Hiring Mistakes

Mistake 1: Hiring for Skills, Not Culture Fit

Why it fails: Brilliant jerks destroy teams. Culture fit matters more than résumé.

The fix: Include team in interviews. Weight “would I want to work with this person?” as heavily as “are they skilled?”

Mistake 2: Hiring Too Senior Too Early

Why it fails: Directors and VPs from big companies struggle with scrappy execution. They want teams and process before shipping.

The fix: Hire senior individual contributors who still love building. Save management hires for 20+ people.

Mistake 3: Hiring Friends and Family

Why it fails: Can’t give honest feedback. Can’t fire if it’s not working. Relationship > performance.

The fix: Keep business and personal relationships separate. If you do hire friends, set expectations upfront about accountability.

Mistake 4: Not Checking References

Why it fails: Résumés lie. Interviews are performances. References reveal reality.

The fix: Always call 2-3 references. Ask hard questions. Listen to what’s not said.

Mistake 5: Optimizing for Cost Over Quality

Why it fails: Cheap talent is expensive. Bad hires cost 3-5x their salary in lost time, morale, and opportunity cost.

The fix: Pay market rate or above. Invest in great people. One exceptional engineer > three mediocre ones.

When to Fire (And How to Do It Right)

Firing is hard. Delaying a necessary firing is worse.

Signs It’s Time to Let Someone Go

  • Not meeting expectations after 60-90 days with clear feedback
  • Culture mismatch that’s affecting the team
  • Dishonesty or ethical violations (immediate termination)
  • Consistent pattern of missed commitments
  • Team morale suffering because of one person

How to Fire with Respect

  1. Document the issues - Have written examples of where they fell short
  2. Give feedback early - Don’t surprise them. They should know it’s coming
  3. Be direct and brief - “This isn’t working out. Today is your last day.”
  4. Offer severance - 2-4 weeks pay if budget allows
  5. Don’t negotiate - The decision is final
  6. Handle logistics quickly - Equipment return, access removal, final paycheck

After the Firing

  • Tell the team what happened (without details)
  • Reassure remaining team members
  • Document what went wrong for future hiring
  • Don’t badmouth the person publicly

Remote vs. Office vs. Hybrid

The pandemic changed this forever. Here’s what works:

Remote-First (My Recommendation)

Pros:

Cons:

  • Harder to build relationships
  • Requires strong documentation culture
  • Time zone coordination
  • Some people struggle with isolation

When it works best:

  • Writing software or designing products
  • Distributed customer base
  • Strong written communication culture

Office-First

Pros:

  • Easier collaboration
  • Faster feedback loops
  • Organic relationship building
  • Clear work/life boundary

Cons:

  • Limited talent pool (local only)
  • Expensive (office rent, commute time)
  • Harder to hire top talent (they want remote)
  • Defaults to measuring presence over outcomes

When it works best:

  • Hardware products
  • Regulated industries
  • Team needs high-bandwidth collaboration

Hybrid (Hardest to Execute)

Pros:

  • Flexibility for those who want it
  • Some in-person time

Cons:

  • Creates two classes (office vs. remote)
  • Meetings exclude remote people
  • Office becomes default, remote becomes disadvantage

If you do hybrid:

  • Default to remote for all meetings (even if some are in office)
  • Rotate who comes in so it’s not always the same people
  • Make office optional, not required

Scaling from 10 to 50 People

Once you’re past the first 10 hires, the game changes:

New Roles You’ll Need

VP of Engineering (at 15-20 engineers)

  • Owns technical vision and architecture
  • Manages engineering team leads
  • Hiring and performance management
  • Scales engineering culture

VP of Product (at 10-15 product people)

  • Owns product strategy and roadmap
  • Manages product managers
  • Customer insights and research
  • Product/market fit evolution

Head of Design (at 5+ designers)

  • Design system and standards
  • Manages design team
  • Design ops and tooling
  • Design/engineering collaboration

Management Structure

You’ll need team leads/managers at 5-7 direct reports per manager.

Example at 30 people:

  • CEO (you)
    • VP Engineering (12 engineers: 3 teams of 4)
    • VP Product (8 PMs + designers: 2 teams of 4)
    • Operations/Finance (3 people)
    • Marketing/Sales (5 people)

Processes That Start to Matter

At 20+ people you need:

  • Performance reviews (quarterly)
  • Career development frameworks
  • Compensation bands
  • Hiring process standardization
  • Onboarding program
  • All-hands meetings (weekly)

Before 20 people, keep it lean and informal.

Your First 90 Days: New Team Member Onboarding

Great onboarding 10x’s time-to-productivity. Here’s the framework:

Week 1: Context and Culture

Day 1:

  • Welcome + setup (laptop, accounts, tools)
  • Intro to team (1-on-1s with everyone)
  • Company mission and vision
  • Product demo and customer stories

Days 2-5:

  • Read documentation and codebase
  • Shadow customer calls
  • Small starter task (fix a bug, design a small feature)
  • Daily check-ins with manager

Week 2-4: Supported Shipping

  • Own a small feature end-to-end
  • Pair with team members
  • Join customer research sessions
  • Start participating in planning

Week 5-12: Full Ownership

  • Own a project independently
  • Present work to team
  • Contribute to strategy discussions
  • Mentor newer team members

Success Metrics

After 90 days, new hire should:

  • Ship at least one meaningful feature
  • Understand product and customers deeply
  • Work independently with minimal oversight
  • Feel excited about the mission

If not, something went wrong in hiring or onboarding.

Tools Your Team Needs

Don’t overthink this. Here’s the essential stack:

Communication:

  • Slack or Discord
  • Zoom or Google Meet
  • Loom for async video

Product Management:

  • Linear, Jira, or Asana
  • Notion or Confluence for docs
  • Figma for design

Development:

  • GitHub or GitLab
  • Vercel, Railway, or Render for hosting
  • Sentry for error tracking
  • PostHog or Mixpanel for analytics

Operations:

  • Google Workspace
  • 1Password
  • Gusto or Rippling for payroll

Start with free tiers. Upgrade when you have revenue.

Conclusion: Build the Team That Builds the Product

Your product is only as good as the team building it.

Hire slowly. Fire quickly. Pay well. Trust people. Measure outcomes, not hours. Build a culture where great people want to stay.

The best teams aren’t built with perfect hiring processes or org charts. They’re built by founders who care deeply about the people building alongside them.

Start small. Hire for culture fit and potential, not just résumés. Create an environment where people do their best work. The rest will follow.

Next steps:

  • Define your first hire based on your gaps
  • Write a compelling job description focused on mission
  • Post in communities and tap your network
  • Interview 5-10 candidates before making an offer
  • Invest in great onboarding

Building a team is hard. But there’s nothing more rewarding than watching people you believed in become better than you ever imagined.

Related Reading: